I have only been to Chelsea once before, for a beer and some pizza, but have wanted to go back for more than a year. The menu looks so enticing and the selection of beer is fairly good – better than your average restaurant. As you enter the restaurant, you walk into a welcoming bar area – it is well-lit with nice wooden tables – a good place to eat if you want something slightly more casual. You then walk back into the dining area, there are both booths and tables – the lighting is slightly dimmed for a slightly romantic ambience.
We sat at one of the tables in the middle of room – they are close together, so I felt that the couples on either side of us were way too close, but after my beer came, I perked up. We started out with the House Made Soft Pretzel Crullers, served with Queso Poblano sauce. The pretzels were just a touch too hard for my liking, but they were not overly buttery and barely salted. And the Queso dip – delicious. Perhaps the pretzels had been apart of another batch – I’d be willing to give them a second taste test.
As my main course, I had the Wild Mushroom Soup (which, sadly, is not on their current menu) and the Baby Spinach salad. The soup was to die for, honestly. It was mushroomy, but had a touch of cream in the middle and topped with just a hint of pesto. There were a few mushroom chunks – and all this added up to be so tasty – my mouth is actually watering as I think about it. If you don’t like mushrooms, then this isn’t the soup for you, but if you even slightly like them, I would recommend trying it (if they add it back to the menu). I also had the Baby Spinach Salad. It was very lightly dressed – a little bit more dressing would have done the salad good. It was okay – not great for a salad. I thought that I would like the dressing more, but it was nothing spectacular.
For dessert, we attempted to please both of our palettes and ordered the Chocolate Chocolate Cake. Well, the cake was good, and so was the ice cream, but the spicy caramel sauce – way too much! And that’s not just me saying it because I don’t like caramel – my husband agreed that it was too spicy for a dessert. I have definitely learned that spicy desserts are not what I like. We were able to scrape a lot of the caramel sauce off of the cake so that we could enjoy it, but the taste mostly stayed with us for the rest of the night – kind of a bummer.
Overall, Chelsea has a nice atmosphere and tasty food. I would recommend it for the vegetarian restaurant-goer. FYI – They also have a downstairs room with a bar for private events – right beside the wine cellar!
September 2012 Update:
On a recent visit to Chelsea, I enjoyed the Hand Cut Signature Trio Fries appetizer and Veggie Margherita pizza. The fries consisted of crispy Vidalia Onions, Idaho & Sweet Potatoes and were seasoned with a homemade spice. They were paired with a house aioli. The aioli was a tad spicy, perfect for my taste! All of the fries were crispy, but some were slightly burnt. I think I’d get the dish again if I went with a group of people to share it with. I then had the Veggie Margherita pizza that comes out of the brick oven in the back of the dining area (a nice one, made of light-colored stone). The pizza has a plum tomato sauce, mozzarella, basil, wild mushrooms, red onion, and roasted peppers (I opted to nix the olives). It had a crispy crust and was slightly browned on the top (no burning for this item!). It was a tasty pizza that I would definitely order again.
May 2013 Update:
My mother and stepdad came to visit over Mother’s Day weekend. We treated them to dinner at Chelsea Tavern in downtown Wilmington. My husband and I had ordered the House Made Soft Pretzel Crullers as an appetizer on a previous trip and didn’t much care for them, but he is on a soft pretzel kick, so we ordered them for the four of us. Boy, am I glad that I gave these a second try! They were soft and chewy and not drowned in butter like some soft pretzels. They were served with a spicy Dog Fish Head 60 Minute I.P.A. cheese sauce – delish! Not really that spicy, but definitely tasty.
As my main dish, I ordered the Chelsea Pizza. It has a shallot and garlic spread and is topped with tomatoes, sautéed spinach, herbed ricotta cheese, and a bit of mozzarella. I love getting pizza at Chelsea because they serve it with your own little tri-bowl of parmesan, Italian herbs, and red pepper flakes. I also loved this pizza! Of course, that probably has something to do with all of the cheese on it. The crust was thin, but not crusty or burnt – cooked just right in their brick oven. The veggies were soft and chewy and I loved the garlicky taste that the sauce imparted on each bite. I cannot wait to go back to Chelsea because I will definitely order this again.