My return to Buckley’s Tavern was bittersweet. The owners of the tavern chose not to renew the lease with the current chef there, so as of January 15, 2012, there is no more Buckley’s in Centreville, DE. I actually had the opportunity to go there twice in the weeks before they closed. Once with my husband because I wanted to go one last time. The second for a meeting (planned after I had gone with my husband). I was really happy to show up and see that there menu had been expanded to include even more vegetarian options. Of course, since they were closing, this really had no bearing on any future visits.
My husband and I went there for lunch on January 2. They were already starting to fall short on beer and food supplies. My Simple Salad was supposed to have some more veggies, but the arugula, tomatoes, and citrus vinaigrette satisfied my need. The tomatoes were chopped a tad to large, but the sweet vinaigrette (not too sweet!) made up for that. The salad was well-dressed, not dry and not dripping. For my main course, I ordered the Vietnamese BBQ Tofu sandwich. It had tofu grilled with BBQ sauce slathered on it, cilantro, chipotle mayo, lettuce, carrots, and cucumber and was served on a baguette. It was too large and messy to eat as a sandwich, so I ate the various components of it separately and removed cilantro because I'm not a fan. The chipotle mayo wasn’t too spicy and was actually pretty tasty (considering I’m no fan of mayo). Overall, the meal was fine, but I kind of expected the tofu to at least be marinated in the BBQ Sauce. For dessert, I gave in and we ordered the Caramel Apple bread pudding. It was a large, thick slice of bread drenched in caramel. The bread was some sort of apple bread - some of the apples were crunchy, which gave it a weird texture. The caramel was thick and gooey and seeped into bread. For those who like caramel, it would have been nice. For me, not so much.
My second experience was better. I ordered the Chicken Sausage Pizza w/ veggie sausage. The individual pizza was fairly large – about 6 slices. The dough was not too crunchy and the base, instead of a marinara, was a garlic cream sauce. Very tasty. The cheese and vegetarian sausage made it even better. The sausage was the crumbled style and slightly crunchy from being baked with the pizza. I was much happier with this selection, but very upset when my husband ate all of the leftovers the next day. J